Sunday, November 24, 2019

The Katha Upanishad - Mortality and Immortality Personified

The Katha Upanishad ...


In one sense a "children's" story, which may find good company amidst a creepy campfire collection, yet with surprisingly advanced themes, the Katha Upanishad (कठोपनिषद् / कठ उपनिषद्) is a Sanskrit text of India dating to roughly the fifth century before the common era. It tells the tale of a young boy, Naciketas, son of the sage Vājashravas, and his encounters with the personification of Death.

Existential in content, the Katha Upanishad depicts lessons imparted by Death to the young Naciketas about the nature of the soul, Ātman, and its liberation, Moksha/Mokṣa. Despite his youth, Naciketas bravely confronts the reality of morality. Such topics are by no means off limits. Even children may die young.

Here dissect both the flesh and bones of death, examining the chapter-wise structure of the Katha Upanishad, its skeleton, while also fleshing out its content, the beating heart and soul that fills it with life, animating the text as corpus, as corpse. Halloween may be behind us, but death is always looming.



Mortality and Immortality


Setting the stage for the Katha Upanishad is an impactful image of death, shown to us at the very outset of its treatment of mortality. At the beginning of the text, in its very first chapter, the young Naciketas beholds an existential scene unfolding before his eyes. Watching cows being led to their slaughter, for the sake of ritual sacrifice, the curious child asks his father: Who will receive the sacrifice? In response to his son's inquiry, Vājashravas names "Death."

Naciketas thus begins his confrontation with life's final moments and the afterlife that follows. In the course of his education, both mortality and immortality show their faces. During his contemplations, Naciketas symbolically stays as “guest” in the “house” of Death, a central character in the encounter who oddly grants him three wishes.

Interestingly, Naciketas asks:

  • 1. To be greeted with joy upon death

  • 2. For "Death" (the character) to explain how a man with faith enjoys immortality in heaven

  • 3. Whether a man who is dead exists or does not exist

Skirting around these questions, particularly the last, the personification of Death replies that such an inquiry is too complex — even the gods do not understand the nature of death and existence. Being but a child, perhaps Death underestimates Naciketas, dismissing him as lacking the spiritual maturity to comprehend what even the gods cannot fathom. Thus, Naciketas is asked to make an alternative wish in place of his question.

A stubborn child, perhaps determined to find an answer, Naciketas stands by his original question about death. Attempting to dissuade him, the character "Death" offers to fulfill Naciketas’s desires with material goods. Even so, Naciketas is unrelenting, acknowledging that material wealth is impermanent and ultimately unsatisfactory, demanding an answer to his question instead.

The Abode of Death


Given the child's unyielding persistence, Death realizes that Naciketas genuinely yearns for knowledge. Indeed, Death is forced to admit that the young boy, unusual for a mortal, much more for a child, remains unblinded by worldly desires. Evidently quite mature for his age, Naciketas confirms his advanced insights, noting, “What you call a treasure, I know to be transient; for by fleeting things one cannot gain the perennial.” Recognizing the boy's sincerity, Death reflects that for the vast majority, “satisfying desire is the foundation of the world,” but seeing that Naciketas has gone beyond this, offers the boy his “house.”

Accepting this invitation, Naciketas enters the abode of Death.

Deeming Naciketas as worthy of an answer upon bravely entering the abode of Death, it comes time to impart a core contemplative practice for the young boy's use. Given their undeniable presence and persistence, his spiritual inclinations should be nurtured. Death thus reveals the syllable “Om” (ॐ) which he deems the secret to obtaining one’s every wish. Psychologically, the vibrations its chanting induces exert a powerful calming and quieting effect over the otherwise scattered mind. In response to his question, Naciketas is informed by Death that the wise one is not born and does not die. Such is the eternal, imperishable soul, Ātman.



The Chariot


In the Katha Upanishad's discussion of Ātman, broadly representing the self or soul, we find the image of the chariot make its appearance. Also employed in Buddhist contexts, in the Katha Upanishad the chariot stands for the body. Its rider, the one holding the reins, is the eternal self, imperishable soul, Ātman.

All that is composed of myriad component parts must also decompose, dis-integrate, deteriorate—a lesson of the Katha Upanishad instilled in the young Naciketas by none other than Death, himself. Only Ātman is eternal, unified, whole without parts. The analogy is outlined in detail:

Ātman is the rider, while the body is the chariot.
Intellect is the charioteer, while mind is symbolized by the reins.
The senses are horses, while sense objects are the paths around them.

With these parallels, one may perhaps visualize a battle scene, with each character, each aspect of what we may typically consider a "being," depicted by each symbol. Ātman takes up the body as its vehicle, like a rider in a chariot, with its senses galloping toward sense objects, like horses navigating winding paths. Naciketas learns that Ātman is "the one who enjoys," the one who remains even when the chariot falls apart and its horses scatter.

Self-Control


Upon receiving this metaphor of the chariot, Naciketas also learns the importance of self control. As a young boy, he intuitively grasps what often takes people decades to understand, some entering old age without ever having learned. Namely, with mind uncontrolled, the senses disobey their master and one experiences sorrow, dissatisfaction, unease. However, with mind controlled, the senses obey their master and one experiences the complete and utter bliss of self-control. In like manner to a charioteer's reins controlling the direction taken by horses, the mind routes and re-routes the senses.

Mastery of this ability requires extensive training in self-control, but once achieved, the imperishable Ātman is at complete peace.

Consistent with other Upanishadic teachings, Naciketas also learns that God, Brahman is supreme. Not only that, but God is not separate from us. The contemplative path, which includes exercises in self-control, reunites us with God. For Upanishadic contemplatives, Brahman is the ultimate reality — the immortal, the pure, the source of all. Given their non-separation, both Brahman and Ātman are radiant, like light.

Most importantly, Naciketas learns that while fools seek externally for the divine, the wise look within. Here, one experiences liberation, Moksha/Mokṣa.



Yoga as Union


This reorientation, from seeking externally to turning within, reconnects us to God in the broad "Hindu" tradition, largely shaped by texts such as the Katha Upanishad. Drawing a distinction between the material and the immaterial worlds, the Katha Upanishad teaches that the soul is its own substance distinct from yet interacting with the senses and body. Whereas the senses and body come and go, only Brahman and Ātman are eternal.

Naciketas learns that knowing Brahman and Ātman, not merely intellectually, but in their totality through spiritual contemplation is the practice of yoga. Here, we may understand yoga as union, the seamless yoking together of Brahman and Ātman, which were never separate in the first place but are only misperceived as such by the unsettled mind. Understanding their union entails access to true immortality in the Upanishadic worldview.

We hope this abbreviated exploration of the Katha Upanishad illuminates the timeless wisdom of this Indian classic and its relevance to continued encounters with Death, a timeless existential truth. To be continued.

Wednesday, November 20, 2019

Contemplative Characters Contemporary to the Buddha

Contemplative Characters ...




In an age of doctrinal diversity, the modern era filled to its brim with competing political factions, religious sects, and personality cults, a basic "literacy" of such positions is helpful for navigating the increasingly uncertain ideological terrain that lies before us. Likewise for the Buddha's time.

Most know that the Buddha lived in what we now know to be northern India near the border with Nepal, his earliest teachings preserved in the Pāli language, others in Sanskrit and related dialects. While those encountering Buddhism in the present day and age are usually aware of the broad context in which the Buddha lived and taught, few are familiar with other spiritual teachers active in the same period. The Buddha certainly was not the only contemplative of his time.

Perhaps we may acquire a clearer understanding of the philosophies relevant and contemporary to the Buddha by investigating those philosophers he addresses by name, including, most notably, all who receive mention in an early text of the Pāli Canon from the Dīgha Nikāya, titled the Sāmaññaphala Sutta.

In particular, these teachers mentioned by the Buddha include:
  • Pūraṇa Kassapa
  • Makkhali Gosāla
  • Ajita Kesakambalī
  • Pakudha Kaccāyana
  • Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta
  • Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta

Each contemplative, in turn, had his own worldview or philosophy, his own teaching which he sought to impart to others. In this article, we wish to provide brief doctrinal biographies of contemplative characters contemporary to the Buddha for the sake of better understanding the contemplative context in which he lived and taught.



Amoralism and Pūraṇa Kassapa the Naturalist


The first contemplative to be mentioned in the Sāmaññaphala Sutta went by the name Pūraṇa Kassapa. He was a contemplative of the Buddha's time associated with amoralism, summarized by the Pāli term "akiriyaṃ," reflecting his belief that there are no evil acts or fruits of evil acts. Likewise, for Pūraṇa Kassapa, there were no good acts nor fruits of good acts. The kiriya in the term "akiriyaṃ" means "action" or "activity" and is closely associated with the more commonly recognized form karma in Sanskrit, or kamma in Pāli. Pūraṇa Kassapa was also known as an ahetuvadin, a denier of causality.

By asserting that there are neither actions nor the fruits (or results) of actions, Pūraṇa Kassapa denied the operation of karma. While it is important to note that there are multiple versions of karma, the pre-Buddhist notion tending toward a deterministic version and the Buddhist variation allowing a significant place for the role of intention or volition, all theories of karma entailed some understanding of the connection between cause and effect, act and result.

Pūraṇa Kassapa, however, believed that there would be no reward for good acts and no punishment for evil acts. One could practice giving and other virtuous acts but acquire no merit whatsoever. One could murder and steal yet not reap any consequences, in his view. The Buddha found this perspective to be dangerous and thus rejected it. Notably, Pūraṇa Kassapa, who believed himself to be omniscient, is said to have committed suicide by drowning, perhaps finding no point in living, death being his destiny anyway. We start off on a somewhat dark note by summarizing his doctrinal biography here.

Determinism and Makkhali Gosāla the Fatalist


Makkhali Gosāla, on the other hand, was a devoted "ājīvika," literally one who acts according to livelihood, also contemporary to the Buddha. He was a proponent of determinism or fatalism (niyativāda), according to which all that one experiences has been written in stone and there is no changing the course of events inscribed in one's fate. Makkhali Gosāla and his supporters followed their "ājīvika" livelihood not out of choice, but because it was pre-ordained.

Notably, Makkhali Gosāla used the notion of "saṃsārasuddhiṃ" (wandering on) to advance the belief that there are no causes or conditions within one's control for defilement or purification. In other words, one is absolutely powerless, as these factors are pre-destined. He and his followers denied the existence of free will.

What purpose, then, is there to any activity whatsoever? On face value, such a philosophy could easily lend itself to the spectrum of passive indifference, catatonia, or to a form of hedonism in which anything goes given that it's all pre-determined and outside one's control anyway. Makkhali Gosāla's teachings may have been popular among some, but the Buddha was not impressed.

Annihilationism and Ajita Kesakambalī the Materialist


Also contemporary to the Buddha was a contemplative character by the name of Ajita Kesakambalī, who taught a form of annihilation, according to which everything is annihilated, destroyed, obliterated upon death. His response to questions about his teaching can be summed up by the Pāli term "ucchedaṃ," literally referring to complete destruction.

Also associated with materialism (lokāyata), Ajita Kesakambalī emphasized only the present life, without recourse to past or future lifetimes. In other words, this life is all we have. According to Ajita Kesakambalī and the materlialists, all we are is composed of matter that is doomed to decay. Nothing survives or continues post-mortem.

Such a materialist and annihilationist worldview in the Buddha's time most often lent itself to a denial of morality. Even if moral causality operates within a single lifetime, it ends upon death. The Buddha avoided this sort of slippery slope by rejecting the extreme view of annihilationism, finding it limiting and even unskillful to teach. Others could easily get the wrong idea and begin to act irresponsibly, thinking "you only live once" and neglecting to take future ramifications into consideration.

Eternalism and Pakudha Kaccāyana the Amoral Atomist


Meanwhile, another contemplative named Pakudha Kaccāyana who was around at the same time as the Buddha advocated a form of eternalism (sassatavāda) based on a Pāli statement attributed to him, "aññena aññaṃ," meaning "something else" and amounting to a form of evasion. Rather than moral teachings, Pakudha Kaccāyana was pre-occupied with other matters.

Taking a somewhat scientific turn, Pakudha Kaccāyana was a contemplative mainly concerned with atomic theory. He summarized his insights to his followers through reference to seven eternal, non-interacting "elements," including earth, water, fire, air, pleasure, pain, and life. We may recognize and acknowledge the first four as elements, but to include pleasure, pain, and life as elements perhaps sounds unusual. Regardless of its peculiarity, Pakudha Kaccāyana regarded each as eternal building-blocks comprising reality as we know it.

Drawing from this theories of eternalism and atomism, Pakudha Kaccāyana proposed a form of amoralism, denying, for instance, that there is anyone who kills and no act of killing despite what otherwise would count as murder. Pakudha Kaccāyana claimed, in a rather reductionist manner, that a bladed weapon, when used against another, passes only through the seven substances. Nothing more. Nothing moral. The atoms would merely disperse and, given their eternality, would re-assemble elsewhere. This is a startling conclusion to reach, and the Buddha rejected it outright.

Agnosticism and Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta the Eel-Wriggler


Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta, a rather curious contemplative character, is associated with agnosticism (ajñana, literally not knowing or without knowledge) due to his strategic use of a debate technique known at the Buddha's time as "vikkhepaṃ" or evasion and equivocation.

Rather than put forth any coherent philosophy, Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta remained skeptical and uncommitted, which became a doctrine of its own, known in Pāli as amarāvikkhepavada, connoting endless equivocation. His response was often some variety of, "I don't think so. I don't think in that way. I don't think otherwise. I don't think not. I don't think not not."

Due to his use of this "neti neti" ("neither this nor that") response, Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta became associated with the "eel-wrigglers" (amarāvikkhepika) whose name characterizes their evasive efforts to wriggle themselves out of providing an answer when questioned, like a slippery eel squirming out of its catcher's grasp. The Buddha remained unimpressed with this sort of evasiveness. Whenever the Buddha, for instance, decided not to provide an answer to a question, he gave a legitimate reason. To merely go around saying "I don't think this, I don't think that" perhaps came across as deceptive or even lazy. Dissatisfied, several of Sañjaya Belaṭṭhiputta's followers left him, joining the Buddha instead.

Asceticism and Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta the Jain


Perhaps most familiar to us, as well as to the Buddha, might be Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta, otherwise known as Mahavira, the founder of Jainism. While the other teachers never gathered as much momentum, only Mahavira and the Buddha's legacies became recognized as religions. In fact, Buddhism and Jainism developed side by side, in the same place at the same time. Even visual depictions of Mahavira closely resemble the Buddha, and although their teachings were quite different in several ways, the statues that have been made of them are often confused for each other. While the previous teachers are likely brand new to most of us, Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta founded a major tradition still alive to this day.

Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta's teaching, which has developed into what we now know as Jainism, emphasized the importance of extreme observances, as depicted by the Pāli term "cātuyāmasaṃvaraṃ," meaning "fourfold restraint," as a means of burning off all karma without creating any anew. Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta taught his followers to go to extreme lengths in order to avoid any activity that would generate further existence.

Such methods involved severe dietary restrictions and avoiding even accidental harm to insects and invisible or microscopic beings in the spirit of absolute non-violence. Followers of Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta were asked to abstain from eating all animal products whatsoever, to avoid root vegetables because harvesting them would injure insects in the soil as well as kill the plant and prevent it from re-growing, and carefully filter their water in case there were any microscopic beings inside. Those who still practice Jainism, strictly observing Nigaṇṭha Nātaputta's regulations, may even refrain from walking on grass to avoid stepping on insects, gently sweep the path in front of them to clear it of ants, wear a breathing mask to prevent inhaling invisibly small beings, and so on. While commendable on one hand, the Buddha nonetheless found such observances impractical to demand of everyone and disagreed with the extremes that characterize strict Jainism.



Contemporary to the Buddha


Given that each of these contemplative characters lived contemporary to the Buddha, they undoubtedly influenced the context in which the Buddha formulated his own understanding of the world. We hope that by providing a brief doctrinal biography of each, we have shed light on the core features of their philosophies. While a mere three paragraphs each cannot do justice to the complexities and intricacies of their teachings, we hope they serve as a launching pad for further investigation.

Why should any of this matter to us? That the Buddha was familiar with the doctrines of other contemplatives, despite disagreeing with them, showcases his openness to hearing the perspectives of others. Rather than remaining willfully ignorant of his contemporaries, he made himself aware of what was going on in the contemplative world around him, building a sort of philosophical and contemplative literacy with regard to other emerging traditions.

Likewise, in our present experience, we encounter doctrines from diverse factions, many of them proclaiming themselves to be the sole truth. Rather that grow hostile toward them, or remain ignorant of their messages, we may at least try to understand what they teach. We are not required to agree with any of them in the slightest in the process of learning more about them.

Too often, we assume that multiple points of view cannot coexist in harmony. If we collectively work toward opening space for an understanding that unity can be found within plurality as opposed to conformity, we stand to grow substantially as a global community.

Certainly, if particular beliefs have a tendency to lead to harm for individuals or societies, they should be actively questioned, but not without understanding where they originate, what motivates and fuels them. The Buddha objected to each of the above listed contemplatives and even dismantled many of their doctrines, doing so not from a competitive quest to be the best, but out of a collectively minded effort to discern what conduces to suffering and what conduces to freedom. May all experience the freedom of clear discernment and unity within plurality. Feel free to leave us a comment below.

Sunday, November 17, 2019

Ghalib on Love - Challenges in Pursuit of the Beloved



Ghalib on Love ...


Third in our series of mystical poetry from across the Hindu, Sufi, and Muslim traditions is Ghalib, an Agra-born poet who began writing classical poetry at age 11, composing work in both Urdu and Persian. He lived from 1797 to 1869 during the decline of the Mughal Empire, only a few centuries removed from the present. Continuing our excursion into the love poems of Indic poets, much of Ghalib's poetry also revolves around the theme of mystic love.

Indeed, for Ghalib, what lies hidden and veiled is a primordial love without beginning nor end. Showing both Sufi tendencies as well as Islamic influence, Ghalib cultivated a refined understanding of God's innateness within himself. Similar to Sanai's belief in an infinite inner force, Ghalib also felt that God is a divine power not separate from us, but arises from within our own consciousness as a reflection of our inherent (though often untapped) wellspring of love and compassion.

Here we inquire along with Ghalib, whose poetry asks us: how do we manifest love despite the challenges it poses?

My Religion is Breaking Rules


I believe in one God only; and my religion is breaking rules: (48)



When all sects go to pieces, they’ll become one part of true religion. (48)

Much like Kabir and Sanai who were similarly influenced by Hindu and Muslim teachings yet consciously broke free from established religion, Ghalib was also an independent thinker unbound by the trappings of religious norms and rituals. Knowing religion can be a binding force, Ghalib drew inspiration from those in religious circles yet held himself free from the regimented rules that restricted and constrained much of society.

When one blindly follows traditional practices without understanding the universal principles behind them, this only confines the practitioner to dogmatic religious ideologies, including a rote, abstract concept of love divorced from direct experience. Ghalib frames his religion with the reflection "my religion is breaking rules," believing that such rules stood in the way between man and God, obstructing their union.

Rather than submit to such rules as a means toward union with God, Ghalib remained a skeptic. He felt that union with God could be found not through rote performance of ritual obeisance, but through the wholehearted expression of boundless love for the infinite that is God himself.

Challenges of Love


Such reflections inspired Ghalib to chart his own path of love while grounding himself in a purposeful lived experience. However, such an undertaking by no means unfurled in perfect ease and comfort. In fact, Ghalib’s poems often reflect the painstaking, heart-breaking challenges of love. In the pursuit of his beloved, Ghalib is often at a complete and utter loss. He nevertheless endures the challenges of love, believing that to live out his full potential, he must transform and transcend his self-centeredness. In one poem, he writes:

The blood of my heart has not completely exited through my eyes. O death, let me stay a whole, the work we have is abundant enough. (43)

Given his plea to be spared from death in order to complete and fulfill the expression of his heart's yearnings, Ghalib appears to have unfinished business. Perhaps the poet has not yet exhausted his blood and vital energy into his work. Implied here is the poet’s unencumbered striving to remain in union with his beloved. The path of love requires one to exhaust one’s life breath into the object of desire, which for Ghalib is Allah, God.

Pursuit of the Beloved


Despite his committed, unrelenting pursuit of the beloved, Ghalib consistently faces seemingly insurmountable obstacles. Indeed, he reflects that the path of love is a training ground of sorts for one’s determination, capacity for experimentation, and response to failures.

She has a habit of torture, but doesn’t mean to end the love.

Such oppression is only teasing; we don’t imagine it as a test. (33)

To truly engage and understand such torture and teasing, one must come to embrace that the path is full of obstacles and that such obstacles are no less the path than moments of ecstatic union with the infinite, divine principle. Yet if one pushes too hard against such obstacles or feels it necessary to subject oneself to pain, such pressure can keep one from the goal. For instance, Ghalib writes:

God, I want to know why my desires bring the opposite effect.
The more I try to attract the Great One, the farther away she moves. (37)

Clearly the poet’s love affair is not a case of utter bliss. The beloved or Allah, depicted in feminine form, does not show Ghalib what we typically perceive as loving compassion, but rather, an abrasive dynamic insofar as She retreats from the mind that seeks for something to attain. For Ghalib, Allah by definition is "nothingness," ungraspable and thus unattainable. Despite knowing this, Ghalib continues to pursue Her.



During his pursuit of the beloved, Ghalib reflects that love’s full emergence and consummation requires immense patience:

Love requires waiting, but desire doesn’t want to wait.
The heart has no patience; it would rather bleed to death. (15)

Such patience is a theme he gives ample time and space for reflection.

The spiritual seekers are tired, two or three at each stage of the path.
The rest—who have given up—never knew your address at all. (35)

Only those who have patience will emerge out of their repeated failures and struggles and unravel the secrets of unity, reflects Ghalib.

Macrocosmic and Microcosmic


Ultimately, Ghalib reminds us that we are not separate from everything else, but intimately part of a dynamic process, deeply interrelated with the entire cosmos. Separation or duality is a consequence of ignorance:

If you can’t see the Ganges in a drop and the planet in a grain of sand,
Then your eyes are not adult but the eyes of infants. (31)

The drop grows happy by losing itself in the river.
A pain when beyond human range becomes something else. (45)

In these two couplets, we find images of the macrocosmic and microcosmic seamlessly intermingling. In a single drop can be seen the entire Ganges, while in but one grain of sand the planet spins. By becoming indistinguishable from the river, the droplet is fulfilled, consummated, restored to the innate wholeness it never, in actuality, lacked.



Such reflections imply that perhaps the solitary, separate, selfish ego that perceives itself always in contrast is the ultimate enemy to be vanquished in order for divine love to be sustained. To manifest love, Ghalib demands that the heart must be broken wide-open. Only then may the infinite pour in.

If your heart is still in one piece, cut your chest with a dagger.
If eyelashes are not soaked with blood, put a knife in your heart. (33)

While such imagery is certainly intense, it conveys the painstaking efforts Ghalib invested into reunion with his beloved. As we open our hearts, we gradually empty out the egoic self responsible for erecting prison-like boundaries, thereby limiting our freedom. Similar to Kabir who probed the tendency toward self-centeredness, Ghalib also highlights that our individual, mundane existence symbolically manifests its limitations in the form of playthings with little control over their destinies, guided instead by forces unbeknownst to it.

The world I see looks to me like a game of children.
Strange performances and plays go on night and day. (22)

Unable to see the futility of our grasping immaturity, we become part of a performance or play, enacting every petty thought that arises, not realizing them to be figments of our mind, games of our own creation. Our energy becomes scattered as we follow habituations unquestioningly rather than carefully observing the mind's activity. Thus is our conditioning:

The horse of life is galloping; we’ll never know the stopping place.

Our hands are not touching the reins, nor our feet the stirrups. (19)

In this sense, we lose the goal and life grows meaningless. However, taking back the reins, we have full control of the direction of our mind, thus opening the space for love to manifest. Therefore, resembling the approach of Kabir and Sanai, Ghalib emphasizes that the finite, limited self must die in order to become aware of its undifferentiated essence. He states that death is the cure to the terrible danger of existence:

Oh Ghalib, the sorrows of existence, what can cure them but death? (15)

Death inclines the lover towards everlasting union with the beloved. God is the only purpose that gives him a way out of his deadened, woeful state.

When I see God, color comes into my cheeks. (14)

Reconnection with the loved one (Allah) brings one back to life, which constitutes the very essence of humanity.

Coming Full Circle


Coming full circle, the whole journey towards God brings Ghalib back to the loving, nurturing womb-like vessel of God, from which we emerge and to which we return by following the footsteps of love. Thus, love is not a place to go but a process of continuous unfolding of one’s heart, the embodiment of devotion. The capacity to transform our habit energies based on the embodiment of love lies within the potential for witnessing something greater and bigger.

For the Sufi poets, union with God is the transcendent destination, but most importantly, the dynamic process of love is what kept them deeply interconnected, embodied, and committed to witnessing the unwavering love that lies hidden. Without subject or object, there is no existence and no separate identity, only pure love.

Thus the bond of love is the creative power, the womb of life that binds and holds the wholeness of creation together. In other words, it is the primordial glue that allows for the cohesion of the cosmos, the dynamic dance of unity.



The Lightning Should Have Fallen on Ghalib: Selected Poems of Ghalib. Ecco Press, 1999.